I'm a fan of Backlisted, a podcast that delves into neglected books of the 20th century – many of them English, many of them post-war, many of them by underrated female authors. I like it, for its intellectualism and its unpretentiousness, but I've fallen off. The trouble is I don't like the books very much.
Take Anita Brookner, who may as well be the patron saint of Backlisted. She was English, she was post-war, and she was an incredible intellect; an art historian who wrote contemplative novels about interior life, missed connections, the search for authenticity.
I've read two of her books, and they went down like anesthetic. Grey, Sunday-coloured. A little hung up on the differences between Men and Women. A little prim. I don't want to read any more.
Why not? I'm her target audience. My cultural inheritance can be summed up as post-war English: dogged, frugal, and emotionally stunted. I'm an interior woman. But not like that.
It's the same pattern with the other heavy hitters of Backlisted: Barbara Pym, Elizabeth Taylor (not that one). I get it. I feel it. Quiet tracts on English desperation. Still, get them away from me.
I thought I'd met my match with Rachel Ingalls, an American expat to the UK who wrote the reassuringly weird Mrs. Caliban. It's about a grieving housewife who falls in love with a sexy sea monster – in a grey, understated way. I read it in one sitting, but I never want to read it again.
For a while I left post-war England and went for the recent "comfort reads" of BookTok and tumblr: Legends & Lattes; Red, White & Royal Blue; The Long Way to a Small, Angry Planet. I figured at the very least I'd catch the feeling, the cultural moment. None of them comforted me, and two of them annoyed me.
When I look back over the past few years of reading, it's not the books aimed at my demographic that have made me feel seen. Almost no book cuts closer to me than The Hellbound Heart, the book Clive Barker wrote after hustling in 1970s London. Then he made a movie out of it: Hellraiser.
So what, I'm a horror fan? That was the problem all along? Then why am I reading shoujo now?
I know it's unrealistic to expect your favourite things to have a throughline. The art you love can't add up to some representation of you as a person, because people are complex in a way that art is always catching up to. And the affinities, when they happen, aren't completely intutive. (I suspect my love of Hellraiser is related to my chronic pain.)
Still, I wish it was easier to find the things that you like. We've never had more choice, or more access, and running up against the wrong things until you find a vein of enthusiasm is exhausting.